MY FAVORITE LINER!
This is my favorite! I love the brown even more than the black not only because the brown color gives a little more of a softer feel, but I find that the brown dries quicker than the black and it dries down hard compared to the black liner which dries down tacky. Because the brown, liner dries down hard, it doesn't take any of the liner off with it like I've experienced with the black (and I even let the black dry down for 10 mins). For the black liner, though the lashes really do stick well, I find the lashes end up taking the black liner off with them, leaving magnet gaps on your eyes. I never experience this with the brown though, so I highly recommend the brown formula over the black for the longest wear! SUPER HAPPY WITH THE BROWN LINER! Will definitely be my go to liner when I repurchase! :)